Methodology
How we score supplements
Every Calaca ranking uses a published, points-based rubric that is applied the same way to every product. Below are both rubrics exactly as used, along with how we collect prices.
Last updated
Principles
- Testing first. Independent testing and certification carry the most weight, because public lab rounds keep finding products that don't match their labels.
- Price per effective dose, not per tub. We compare creatine per 5 g and urolithin A per 500 mg.
- Official sources. We link to the store where we found each price and to the registries, test reports and studies we used.
- No paid placement. Brands can't pay to be included or ranked higher. We don't use affiliate links. See our disclosure.
- Flags, not guesses. When we can't confirm something, we mark it “Unverified” or “Brand-stated” instead of filling the gap.
Creatine rubric (100 points)
Used for The best creatine supplements.
Weights
| Criterion | Points |
|---|---|
| Purity testing | 35 |
| Value per 5g | 25 |
| Dose accuracy transparency | 20 |
| Form ingredients | 10 |
| Availability | 10 |
Purity and testing tiers
| Purity/testing tier | Points |
|---|---|
| NSF Certified for Sport or Informed Sport (lot/batch banned-substance + label testing) | 35 |
| NSF CFS shown on brand page but listing not opened | 30 |
| Informed Choice, NSF/ANSI 173 contents certification, or Clean Label Project | 26 |
| Published independent finished-product COAs or Labdoor (brand-paid) report | 22 |
| Brand claim of third-party testing only | 10 |
| Nothing found | 5 |
| Gummy that failed any public lab test round (2024–2025) | -5 |
Other criteria
| Criterion | Rule |
|---|---|
| Value per 5g | 25 × (ln 3.00 − ln price) / (ln 3.00 − ln 0.15), price = USD per 5 g monohydrate-equivalent, clamped to 0.15–3.00 (log scale so pennies matter less at the top end). |
| Dose accuracy transparency | 10 for a fully disclosed label (all products here) + 5 if one labeled serving gives ≥5 g monohydrate-equivalent (3 if 3–5 g, 0 if <3 g) + 5 if an independent program verifies content against the label (NSF CFS, NSF 173, CLP label-claim test, Labdoor, or published independent assay). |
| Form ingredients | 10 unflavored single-ingredient monohydrate powder; 8 monohydrate with one benign add-on (taurine, probiotic); 7 capsules or multi-active blends; 5 HCl powders or chewable tablets; 3–4 gummies (sugar or sugar alcohols, moisture-related degradation risk; 3 if extra nootropic actives). |
| Availability | 10 brand store + Amazon + major US retail; 8 brand store + Amazon; 7 account-gated brand store or limited channels. |
Caveat: Weights are editorial choices for a directory, not a measure of efficacy. A product's certification covers listed lots/flavors only; re-check registries before publishing.
Prices
Price rule: Regular one-time (non-subscription, no coupon) price on the brand's own US store for the size with the lowest cost per gram among normal retail sizes (≤ ~1.2 kg). Where the brand does not sell direct, a major retailer price is used. Observed sale prices are recorded separately but not scored (Black Friday promotions were live).
Price per 5 g: price_per_5g_labeled_compound = list_price / (g per serving × servings) × 5. price_per_5g_monohydrate_equivalent adjusts HCl products for creatine content (monohydrate ≈87.9% creatine, HCl ≈78.2%), so one HCl gram is worth ~0.89 g monohydrate. Ranking uses the monohydrate-equivalent figure.
Price basis: prices read from brand stores or retailer pages on November 18–19, 2026.
Urolithin A rubric (100 points)
Used for The best urolithin A supplements.
Weights
| Criterion | Points |
|---|---|
| Ingredient source clinical backing | 35 |
| Testing purity | 25 |
| Value per 500mg | 20 |
| Transparency | 10 |
| Form usability | 10 |
Rules
| Criterion | Rule |
|---|---|
| Ingredient source clinical backing | 35 = Mitopure at >=500 mg/serving (ingredient used in published RCTs); 25 = Mitopure below 500 mg; 17-19 = generic UA with stated purity and/or independent finished-product test or strong COA; 14 = generic UA, purity not stated, brand COA only; 12 = unverifiable/unavailable. |
| Testing purity | 25 = NSF Certified for Sport + independent pass; 21-24 = NSF content certification or independent pass + GMP cert; 19 = independent pass or SuppCo TESTED + full batch COA; 13-15 = brand COA only; 10 = brand claims only. |
| Value per 500mg | 20 x sqrt(cheapest price-per-500mg / product price-per-500mg), one-time listed price on the check date (square root dampens extremes). Unpriced = 0. |
| Transparency | Full label, purity %, public batch COA incl. heavy metals, claims within evidence; deductions for overstated claims or label-version confusion. |
| Form usability | Single-active capsule/softgel hitting 500-1000 mg in <=2 units = 9; gummy 8; powder 7; 3-capsule blend 6; product needing 4 units to reach 500 mg = 5. |
| Availability penalty | -5 if out of stock/unavailable in the brand's US store or Amazon on the check date. |
Caveats
- Scores for source/testing/transparency/form are editorial judgments applied consistently; publish the rubric with the ranking.
- Prices change frequently (Black Friday sales active on check date); re-verify before publishing.
- Independent potency results come from one SuppCo-commissioned panel (2025), reported via BowTiedPhys/Nootroholic; earlier formula versions may differ from current.
What our scores are not
The weights are editorial choices for comparing products. They don't measure how well a supplement works for you. Certifications cover listed lots, flavors and sizes only, so check the registry for the exact product you buy. We only describe well-established points about each ingredient. Creatine monohydrate at 3–5 g/day is the most-studied form and dose. Urolithin A has been studied for muscle endurance and strength and for mitochondrial markers.
Updates and corrections
Prices and certifications change. Each ranking shows the date it was last checked. When a certification lapses, a product goes out of stock, or a new public test is published, we re-score the product with the same rubric.