Methodology

How we score supplements

Every Calaca ranking uses a published, points-based rubric that is applied the same way to every product. Below are both rubrics exactly as used, along with how we collect prices.

Last updated

Principles

  • Testing first. Independent testing and certification carry the most weight, because public lab rounds keep finding products that don't match their labels.
  • Price per effective dose, not per tub. We compare creatine per 5 g and urolithin A per 500 mg.
  • Official sources. We link to the store where we found each price and to the registries, test reports and studies we used.
  • No paid placement. Brands can't pay to be included or ranked higher. We don't use affiliate links. See our disclosure.
  • Flags, not guesses. When we can't confirm something, we mark it “Unverified” or “Brand-stated” instead of filling the gap.

Creatine rubric (100 points)

Used for The best creatine supplements.

Weights

CriterionPoints
Purity testing35
Value per 5g25
Dose accuracy transparency20
Form ingredients10
Availability10

Purity and testing tiers

Purity/testing tierPoints
NSF Certified for Sport or Informed Sport (lot/batch banned-substance + label testing)35
NSF CFS shown on brand page but listing not opened30
Informed Choice, NSF/ANSI 173 contents certification, or Clean Label Project26
Published independent finished-product COAs or Labdoor (brand-paid) report22
Brand claim of third-party testing only10
Nothing found5
Gummy that failed any public lab test round (2024–2025)-5

Other criteria

CriterionRule
Value per 5g25 × (ln 3.00 − ln price) / (ln 3.00 − ln 0.15), price = USD per 5 g monohydrate-equivalent, clamped to 0.15–3.00 (log scale so pennies matter less at the top end).
Dose accuracy transparency10 for a fully disclosed label (all products here) + 5 if one labeled serving gives ≥5 g monohydrate-equivalent (3 if 3–5 g, 0 if <3 g) + 5 if an independent program verifies content against the label (NSF CFS, NSF 173, CLP label-claim test, Labdoor, or published independent assay).
Form ingredients10 unflavored single-ingredient monohydrate powder; 8 monohydrate with one benign add-on (taurine, probiotic); 7 capsules or multi-active blends; 5 HCl powders or chewable tablets; 3–4 gummies (sugar or sugar alcohols, moisture-related degradation risk; 3 if extra nootropic actives).
Availability10 brand store + Amazon + major US retail; 8 brand store + Amazon; 7 account-gated brand store or limited channels.

Caveat: Weights are editorial choices for a directory, not a measure of efficacy. A product's certification covers listed lots/flavors only; re-check registries before publishing.

Prices

Price rule: Regular one-time (non-subscription, no coupon) price on the brand's own US store for the size with the lowest cost per gram among normal retail sizes (≤ ~1.2 kg). Where the brand does not sell direct, a major retailer price is used. Observed sale prices are recorded separately but not scored (Black Friday promotions were live).

Price per 5 g: price_per_5g_labeled_compound = list_price / (g per serving × servings) × 5. price_per_5g_monohydrate_equivalent adjusts HCl products for creatine content (monohydrate ≈87.9% creatine, HCl ≈78.2%), so one HCl gram is worth ~0.89 g monohydrate. Ranking uses the monohydrate-equivalent figure.

Price basis: prices read from brand stores or retailer pages on November 18–19, 2026.

Urolithin A rubric (100 points)

Used for The best urolithin A supplements.

Weights

CriterionPoints
Ingredient source clinical backing35
Testing purity25
Value per 500mg20
Transparency10
Form usability10

Rules

CriterionRule
Ingredient source clinical backing35 = Mitopure at >=500 mg/serving (ingredient used in published RCTs); 25 = Mitopure below 500 mg; 17-19 = generic UA with stated purity and/or independent finished-product test or strong COA; 14 = generic UA, purity not stated, brand COA only; 12 = unverifiable/unavailable.
Testing purity25 = NSF Certified for Sport + independent pass; 21-24 = NSF content certification or independent pass + GMP cert; 19 = independent pass or SuppCo TESTED + full batch COA; 13-15 = brand COA only; 10 = brand claims only.
Value per 500mg20 x sqrt(cheapest price-per-500mg / product price-per-500mg), one-time listed price on the check date (square root dampens extremes). Unpriced = 0.
TransparencyFull label, purity %, public batch COA incl. heavy metals, claims within evidence; deductions for overstated claims or label-version confusion.
Form usabilitySingle-active capsule/softgel hitting 500-1000 mg in <=2 units = 9; gummy 8; powder 7; 3-capsule blend 6; product needing 4 units to reach 500 mg = 5.
Availability penalty-5 if out of stock/unavailable in the brand's US store or Amazon on the check date.

Caveats

  • Scores for source/testing/transparency/form are editorial judgments applied consistently; publish the rubric with the ranking.
  • Prices change frequently (Black Friday sales active on check date); re-verify before publishing.
  • Independent potency results come from one SuppCo-commissioned panel (2025), reported via BowTiedPhys/Nootroholic; earlier formula versions may differ from current.

What our scores are not

The weights are editorial choices for comparing products. They don't measure how well a supplement works for you. Certifications cover listed lots, flavors and sizes only, so check the registry for the exact product you buy. We only describe well-established points about each ingredient. Creatine monohydrate at 3–5 g/day is the most-studied form and dose. Urolithin A has been studied for muscle endurance and strength and for mitochondrial markers.

Updates and corrections

Prices and certifications change. Each ranking shows the date it was last checked. When a certification lapses, a product goes out of stock, or a new public test is published, we re-score the product with the same rubric.