Creatine · Ranking
The 22 best creatine supplements of 2026, ranked by testing and price
We compared 22 creatine powders, capsules, chews and gummies sold in the US on third-party testing, price per 5 g, dose accuracy, form and availability. Every price is the regular one-time price on the brand's own US store (or a major retailer where the brand doesn't sell direct), checked Nov 18, 2026. Black Friday promotions were excluded.
Last updated · How we score · No paid placement
Top picks
-
Best overall
BulkSupplements.com Creatine Monohydrate (Micronized) Powder – 1 kg
100.0/100 · $0.15 per 5 g
Top score in our ranking and the lowest price per 5 g we found. It holds NSF Certified for Sport listings, but the brand page doesn't mention them, so match your bag's lot number at nsfsport.com.
-
Best value
Naked Nutrition Naked Creatine – Creatine Monohydrate Powder, Unflavored (2.2 lb / 200 servings)
87.5/100 · $0.18 per 5 g
Single-ingredient monohydrate at $0.18 per 5 g with an NSF/ANSI 173 contents certification (per the brand page). Only BulkSupplements costs less.
-
Best gummy
Force Factor Creatine Monohydrate Gummies (150 ct, 30 servings)
78.2/100 · $1.00 per 5 g
The only gummy here that is NSF Certified for Sport for all lots and measured above label (6.3 g vs 5 g) in SuppCo's 2025 test. Still about 7× the cost of the cheapest powder, with roughly 5–6 g sugar.
-
Best for tested athletes
Thorne Creatine (Unflavored) – 180 Servings
90.5/100 · $0.47 per 5 g
NSF Certified for Sport with named listings, a single ingredient, and wide retail availability. If you are drug-tested, confirm your lot on nsfsport.com before use.
Full ranking
Scores are out of 100: purity and testing (35), value per 5 g (25), dose accuracy and transparency (20), form and ingredients (10), and availability (10). The full rubric is on our methodology page.
| Where to buy | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | BulkSupplements.comCreatine Monohydrate (Micronized) Powder – 1 kg | 100.0 | $0.15 | powder | NSF Certified for Sport | bulksupplements.com |
| 2 | ThorneCreatine (Unflavored) – 180 Servings | 90.5 | $0.47 | powder | NSF Certified for Sport | thorne.com |
| 3 | MomentousCreatine – 90 Servings (Signature Spec, Unflavored) | 88.3 | $0.48 | powder | NSF Certified for Sport | livemomentous.com |
| 4 | Naked NutritionNaked Creatine – Creatine Monohydrate Powder, Unflavored (2.2 lb / 200 servings) | 87.5 | $0.18 | powder | NSF/ANSI 173 (brand-stated) | nakednutrition.com |
| 5 | Garden of Life (Nestlé Health Science)Sport Creatine + Probiotics Powder (Unflavored, ~60 servings, 348 g) | 87.2 | $0.55 | powder | NSF Certified for Sport | gardenoflife.com |
| 6 | Animal (Universal Nutrition)Animal Micronized Creatine (Unflavored, 1000 g) | 86.6 | $0.26 | powder | NSF/ANSI 173 | animalpak.com |
| 7 | Klean Athlete (Nestlé Health Science)Klean Creatine (Unflavored, 315 g) | 86.2 | $0.55 | powder | NSF Certified for Sport | kleanathlete.com |
| 8 | Optimum NutritionMicronized Creatine Powder (Unflavored, 240 Servings / 2.64 lb) | 82.6 | $0.23 | powder | Informed Choice | optimumnutrition.com |
| 9 | Force FactorCreatine Monohydrate Gummies (150 ct, 30 servings) | 78.2 | $1.00 | gummy | NSF Certified for Sport | amazon.com |
| 10 | Transparent LabsCreatine HMB (60 Servings) | 77.8 | $1.50 | powder | NSF Sport (unverified) | transparentlabs.com |
| 11 | PuoriC+ – Creatine+ Performance Support (60 servings) | 75.9 | $0.57 | powder | Clean Label Project | puori.com |
| 12 | CON-CRĒTCON-CRĒT® Creatine HCl Powder – Unflavored (100 Servings) | 67.4 | $2.25* | powder | NSF Certified for Sport | con-cret.com |
| 13 | Micro IngredientsMicronized Creatine Monohydrate Powder – Unflavored (1 KG) | 66.4 | $0.23 | powder | Brand claim only | microingredients.com |
| 14 | NutricostCreatine Monohydrate Powder (Unflavored, 1 KG) | 66.3 | $0.23 | powder | Brand claim only | nutricost.com |
| 15 | MuscleTechPlatinum 100% Creatine (Unflavored, 400 g / 80 servings) | 64.6 | $0.29 | powder | Brand claim only | muscletech.com |
| 16 | Create WellnessCreatine Monohydrate Gummies – Tub (90 ct) | 64.5 | $2.22 | gummy | NSF Certified for Sport | trycreate.co |
| 17 | Optimum NutritionMicronized Creatine Capsules (100 Servings / 200 Capsules) | 64.0 | $0.80 | capsule | Informed Choice | optimumnutrition.com |
| 18 | MomentousCreatine Chews 150-Count | 62.9 | $1.67 | chewable tablet | NSF Sport badge (unverified) | livemomentous.com |
| 19 | Legion AthleticsCreatine Gummies (30 servings) | 62.8 | $1.33 | gummy | Labdoor (brand-paid) | legionathletics.com |
| 20 | KagedCreatine HCl™ (75 Servings) | 61.5 | $2.50* | powder | Informed Sport (brand-stated) | kaged.com |
| 21 | CellucorCellucor® Unflavored COR-Performance® Creatine Powder (72 Servings) | 60.3 | $0.26 | powder | None confirmed | cellucor.com |
| 22 | Bear BalancedCreatine Gummies (Blueberry; 30 servings / 90 gummies) | 51.4 | $2.86 | gummy | Published COAs | creatinegummies.com |
*CON-CRĒT and Kaged are creatine HCl. Their price is per 5 g of monohydrate-equivalent creatine (HCl is about 78% creatine by weight vs about 88% for monohydrate). Both brands recommend smaller doses; evidence that smaller HCl doses match 3–5 g of monohydrate is limited.
Key takeaways
- Cheapest isn't worst here. BulkSupplements' 1 kg bag is the lowest price per 5 g in our list ($0.15) and holds NSF Certified for Sport listings. Its own product page doesn't mention this, so check the lot number.
- Premium certified tubs cost about 3× more. Thorne, Momentous, Klean Athlete and Garden of Life all hold NSF Certified for Sport and cost $0.47–$0.55 per 5 g. Momentous says it no longer uses Creapure as of 2026.
- Good value without a sport certification: Naked (NSF/ANSI 173, brand-stated), Animal (NSF/ANSI 173) and Optimum Nutrition powder (Informed Choice). Nutricost, Micro Ingredients, MuscleTech and Cellucor cost about the same but have no public third-party certification we could confirm.
- HCl costs more per gram of creatine. CON-CRĒT and Kaged are certified, but a 750 mg scoop is far below the 3–5 g/day monohydrate dose that has been studied most.
- Gummies are a gamble unless certified. Several independent rounds from 2024–2025 found gummies with little or no creatine. The certified gummies we ranked cost $1.00–$2.86 per 5 g, versus $0.15 for the cheapest powder, and add sugar or sugar alcohols.
All 22 creatine supplements, reviewed
Tags: Unverified means the research could not confirm the claim against a registry or label. Brand-stated means the source is the brand itself.
BulkSupplements.com Creatine Monohydrate (Micronized) Powder – 1 kg
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (micronized), 5 g per serving. None (bag; no scoop-tub). Flavored 700 g versions also NSF-listed.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$29.97 one-time for 200 servings (1000 g) · $0.15 per 5 g
Brand store: 100 g $17.97, 250 g $20.97, 500 g $22.97, 1 kg $29.97; Amazon 1 kg $27.97.
Pros
- Lowest price per 5 g in this list
- NSF Certified for Sport
- Huge Amazon review base
Cons
- Resealable bag, serving measured by teaspoon (brand notes serving sizes may change)
- Brand page does not mention the NSF certification – verify lot at nsfsport.com
Certification
- NSF Certified for Sport (listings 1676955 and 1796571; check lot number)
Check before you buy
- The NSF listing is lot-specific and not mentioned on the brand page. Match your bag's lot number at nsfsport.com.
Thorne Creatine (Unflavored) – 180 Servings
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (micronized), 5 g per serving. None (unflavored). Flavored Strawberry/Pineapple Orange versions (60 servings, $48) add natural flavor, citric acid, malic acid, rebaudioside M (stevia-derived), beet juice color.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$84.00 one-time for 180 servings (900 g) · $0.47 per 5 g
Brand site: $84 / 180 scoops; 90-serving tub $44 (=$0.49 per 5 g).
Pros
- NSF Certified for Sport with named lots
- Single ingredient
- Wide retail availability (Amazon, Walmart, Mayo Clinic store)
Cons
- About 3x the price per 5 g of the cheapest certified option (BulkSupplements)
Certification
- NSF Certified for Sport (listings 1204244 and 1495542)
- NSF/ANSI 173 contents certification (Thorne facility listing)
Momentous Creatine – 90 Servings (Signature Spec, Unflavored)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate ('Signature Spec'; brand states it no longer uses Creapure®), 5 g per serving. None.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$42.99 one-time for 90 servings (450 g) · $0.48 per 5 g
One-time $42.99; subscription $32.24. Product page showed 'Estimated to be back in stock: Soon' for one-time purchase on 2026-11-18.
Pros
- NSF Certified for Sport, all lots
- Publishes per-batch COAs
- Single ingredient
Cons
- Switched away from Creapure in 2026 (older reviews/retail pages still say Creapure)
- Stock interruptions seen on brand site
Certification
- NSF Certified for Sport (listing 1285010, all lots)
- Brand states batch results published and extra PFAS/microplastics screening Brand-stated
Check before you buy
- The one-time purchase option showed “Estimated to be back in stock: Soon” on Nov 18, 2026.
Naked Nutrition Naked Creatine – Creatine Monohydrate Powder, Unflavored (2.2 lb / 200 servings)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (micronized, 200 mesh), 5 g per serving. None (unflavored). Flavored Strawberry/Lemon Lime/Orange versions: 90 servings of 11 g scoops.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$35.99 one-time for 200 servings (1000 g) · $0.18 per 5 g
Brand store $35.99 one-time (1 kg); 1.1 lb ~$21.99–22.99.
Pros
- Single ingredient
- Low price per 5 g
- NSF contents certification
Cons
- NSF 173 checks contents/contaminants but is not the Certified for Sport banned-substance program
Certification
- NSF Contents Certified (NSF/ANSI 173) per brand page Brand-stated
- Informed Choice (reported by SuppCo; not verified here) Unverified
Check before you buy
- Informed Choice status was reported by SuppCo but not verified by us; it is not scored.
Garden of Life Sport Creatine + Probiotics Powder (Unflavored, ~60 servings, 348 g)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (micronized; NutraAssure iCreatine per retailer label), 5 g per serving. Per 5.8 g scoop: 5 g creatine monohydrate + Bacillus subtilis DE111® (1 billion CFU, 10 mg).
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$32.79 one-time for 60 servings (300 g) · $0.55 per 5 g
Brand store $32.79; Amazon $28.69; PureFormulas $24.39.
Pros
- NSF Certified for Sport
- Non-GMO Project Verified
Cons
- Added probiotic raises price; no established benefit of pairing with creatine
- Mid-high price per 5 g
Certification
- NSF Certified for Sport (listing 1580463)
- Non-GMO Project Verified
- NSF Certified Gluten-Free
- Kosher
Animal Micronized Creatine (Unflavored, 1000 g)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (micronized), 5 g per serving. None.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$50.95 one-time for 200 servings (1000 g) · $0.26 per 5 g
Brand store: 300 g $18.50, 500 g $26.75, 1000 g $50.95.
Pros
- Single ingredient
- NSF contents certification
- Made in brand's own US GMP facility
Cons
- Not on NSF Certified for Sport / Informed lists
- Mid-range price per 5 g
Certification
- NSF/ANSI 173 contents certification (Universal Nutrition listing); not NSF Certified for Sport
Klean Athlete Klean Creatine (Unflavored, 315 g)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (retailer labels list Creapure®), 5 g per serving. None.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$34.50 one-time for 63 servings (315 g) · $0.55 per 5 g
2026 SRP $34.50 (brand price list; also PureFormulas and Amazon $34.50). Label says 'approx. 60' servings; 315 g / 5 g = 63 used here. Brand site requires an account to buy.
Pros
- NSF Certified for Sport
- Single ingredient
- Creapure® per retailer labels
Cons
- Smaller tub; mid-high price per 5 g
- Creapure sourcing shown on retailer/older labels but not on every current brand page (uncertain)
- Brand store is account-gated
Certification
- NSF Certified for Sport (listings 1121640 and 1780369)
Check before you buy
- Creapure sourcing appears on retailer and older labels but not on every current brand page.
- Label says “approx. 60” servings; we used 315 g ÷ 5 g = 63.
Optimum Nutrition Micronized Creatine Powder (Unflavored, 240 Servings / 2.64 lb)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (micronized), 5 g per serving. None (unflavored). Flavored 60-serving versions (Mango Orange, Strawberry, Watermelon Lime, Blueberry Lemonade) use 6 g scoops and state no artificial flavors, colors or sweeteners.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$53.99 one-time for 240 servings (1200 g) · $0.23 per 5 g
Brand store: 60 serv $20.49, 120 serv $31.99, 240 serv $53.99.
Pros
- Low price per 5 g from a major brand
- Informed Choice certified
- Sold almost everywhere
Cons
- Not NSF Certified for Sport
- Informed Choice screens banned substances, not label-claim potency
Certification
- Informed Choice (certified 10-Feb-2020; banned-substance screening of retail lots)
Force Factor Creatine Monohydrate Gummies (150 ct, 30 servings)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate + AstraGin®, 5 g per serving. Per 5 gummies: 5 g creatine monohydrate, 25 mg AstraGin®; tapioca syrup, cane sugar, water, pectin, citric acid, natural flavors, fruit/vegetable juice color, sodium citrate. ~5–6 g sugar.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$29.99 one-time for 30 servings (150 g) · $1.00 per 5 g
Brand site does not sell direct (shows $0.00 per third-party review); Amazon $29.99 (also Walmart, CVS).
Pros
- NSF Certified for Sport
- Measured 6.3 g vs 5 g label in SuppCo 2025
- Cheapest gummy per 5 g here
Cons
- 5 gummies/day with ~5–6 g added sugar
- Reported high creatinine in SuppCo test (The Barbell)
- Not sold on own site
Certification
- NSF Certified for Sport (listing 1779617, all lots)
Transparent Labs Creatine HMB (60 Servings)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate + HMB (myHMB®), 5 g per serving. Per serving: 5 g creatine monohydrate, 1.5 g HMB (myHMB®), vitamin D3 500 IU, 5 mg BioPerine® black pepper extract. 13 flavors; flavored versions use natural flavors and stevia-type sweetener (no artificial sweeteners per brand).
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$89.99 one-time for 60 servings (300 g) · $1.50 per 5 g
Brand store: 30 sv $49.99, 60 sv $89.99.
Pros
- Full 5 g creatine plus HMB in one scoop
- Multiple certifications
- Many flavors
Cons
- Most expensive powder per 5 g creatine in this list
- HMB/BioPerine add cost; evidence for added benefit over creatine alone is weaker than for creatine itself
Certification
- NSF Certified for Sport (per NSF register as reported by third-party reviewers; listing not opened here) Unverified
- Informed Choice (brand claim) Brand-stated
- Labdoor A grade listed
Check before you buy
- NSF Certified for Sport status comes from third-party reviewers; we did not open the NSF listing. Informed Choice is a brand claim.
Puori C+ – Creatine+ Performance Support (60 servings)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate + taurine, 5 g per serving. Per 5.4 g scoop: 5 g creatine monohydrate, 400 mg taurine. Unflavored.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$34.00 one-time for 60 servings (300 g) · $0.57 per 5 g
Brand store $34.00 one-time; $28.90 subscription.
Pros
- Batch-level contaminant and label-claim results published
- Unflavored, two ingredients
Cons
- Not a banned-substance (sport) certification
- Taurine add-on; mid-high price
Certification
- Clean Label Project Certified + Purity Award (Puori certificate DSP0007)
- Per-batch COA (Ellipse Analytics, ISO 17025) – lot 118462 passed label-claim accuracy, heavy metals, pesticides
CON-CRĒT® Creatine HCl Powder – Unflavored (100 Servings)
What it contains
Creatine hydrochloride (patented Creatine HCl), 750 mg per scoop. Unflavored: creatine HCl only. Flavored versions (Orange Cream, Lemon Lime, Raspberry, Pineapple, Hibiscus Breeze) exist.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$29.99 one-time for 100 servings (75 g) · $2.25 per 5 g monohydrate-equivalent
Brand store: 64 servings $24.99, 100 servings $29.99. Brand promotes 'micro-dosing' by body weight; NSF 173 listing gives a daily serving of 5 scoops (3,750 mg).
Pros
- NSF Certified for Sport
- Very small scoop, dissolves easily
Cons
- 750 mg per scoop – far below the 3–5 g/day monohydrate dose used in most research
- Claims of superior absorption/no bloating are brand claims; head-to-head evidence vs monohydrate is limited
- Highest cost per 5 g of creatine among powders
- Note: CON-CRĒT gummies (not this powder) failed NOW Foods' 2024 gummy test
Certification
- NSF Certified for Sport (listings 1620371, 1693177)
- NSF/ANSI 173 listing
Micro Ingredients Micronized Creatine Monohydrate Powder – Unflavored (1 KG)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (micronized), 5 g per serving. None.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$45.95 one-time for 200 servings (1000 g) · $0.23 per 5 g
Brand store: 500 g $22.95 (reg. $27.95); 1 kg $39.95 (reg. $45.95). Amazon 1 kg ~$28.99; iHerb/PureFormulas $29.99.
Sale price seen: $39.95 (not used in scoring).
Pros
- Cheap per gram (especially on Amazon/iHerb)
- Single ingredient
Cons
- No public third-party certification found
- Brand-site price higher than marketplaces
Certification
- Brand says ingredients are third-party tested; no NSF/Informed/Labdoor listing found Brand-stated
Nutricost Creatine Monohydrate Powder (Unflavored, 1 KG)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (micronized); separate Creapure® SKU exists, 5 g per serving. Unflavored: none. Many flavors (Blue Raspberry, Fruit Punch, etc.) – sweetener details not confirmed.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$46.97 one-time for 200 servings (1000 g) · $0.23 per 5 g
Brand store: 300 g $18.97, 500 g $23.97, 1 kg $46.97 (500 g is actually cheaper per gram: $0.24 per 5 g). Black Friday code BF2026 (40% off) not applied. Creapure version $42.97.
Pros
- Low price
- Many sizes and flavors
- Retail availability (Amazon, Target, Kroger banners)
Cons
- No NSF/Informed listing found
- Prop 65 lead warning on product page (common on supplements; not a test result)
Certification
- Brand states independent accredited-lab testing (no public certificate found) Brand-stated
Check before you buy
- Nutricost was included in ConsumerLab's June 2026 creatine review, but those results are paywalled and were not used.
MuscleTech Platinum 100% Creatine (Unflavored, 400 g / 80 servings)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (micronized), 5 g per serving. Unflavored: none. Orange Splash, Grape Freeze, Red Berry flavors (sweeteners not confirmed).
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$22.99 one-time for 80 servings (400 g) · $0.29 per 5 g
Brand store $22.99 (all flavors). Unflavored 400 g = 80 servings per retailer labels; flavored tubs are 60 servings (Stack3d).
Pros
- Low price
- Big-box availability
Cons
- No third-party certification found
Certification
- Brand states HPLC-tested; no NSF/Informed registry entry found (AllAboutCreatine, Oct 2026) Brand-stated
Check before you buy
- Serving count for the unflavored tub (80) comes from retailer labels; flavored tubs are 60 servings.
Create Wellness Creatine Monohydrate Gummies – Tub (90 ct)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (older pages said Creapure®; current packaging images labelled 'NoCreapure' – uncertain), 4.5 g per serving. Creatine monohydrate, tapioca syrup, sugar, reverse-osmosis water, pectin, allulose, natural flavor, plant colors (turmeric/spirulina), malic and citric acid. ~5 g sugar per 3-gummy serving (NSF listing).
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$60.00 one-time for 30 servings (135 g) · $2.22 per 5 g
Brand store: Tub 90 ct $60 (3 gummies = 4.5 g); 30-sachet pouch $72.50. Amazon 90 ct ~$49.98.
Pros
- NSF Certified for Sport
- Passed SuppCo June 2025 test (4.59 g vs 4.5 g label)
- Vegan pectin base
Cons
- Failed NOW Foods' Feb-2024 test (1,278 mg vs 1,500 mg per gummy, ~85%) – brand disputed with its own Eurofins data
- SuppCo found 7,300 ppm creatinine (degradation product)
- 4.5 g serving; ~10x powder cost per 5 g
- Contains sugar
Certification
- NSF Certified for Sport (listings incl. 1782317, 1782313, 1782311 – all lots for most flavors)
Check before you buy
- Older pages said Creapure; current packaging images reference “NoCreapure”. Sourcing is unconfirmed.
Optimum Nutrition Micronized Creatine Capsules (100 Servings / 200 Capsules)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (micronized), 2.5 g per serving. Gelatin, magnesium stearate (not vegetarian).
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$39.99 one-time for 100 servings (250 g) · $0.80 per 5 g
Brand store: 100 caps $22.99, 200 caps $39.99, 300 caps $57.49. Serving = 2 capsules = 2.5 g; 5 g/day = 4 capsules.
Pros
- No mixing
- Informed Choice certified
- Widely stocked (Amazon, Target, grocery)
Cons
- 4 capsules for a 5 g day
- ~3.5x the cost per 5 g of the same brand's powder
- Gelatin capsule
Certification
- Informed Choice (certified 24-Oct-2019)
Momentous Creatine Chews 150-Count
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (Signature Spec), 5 g per serving. Pressed-powder chewable tablet; flavors Lemon Lime, Mango, Strawberry. Full excipient list not confirmed; a third-party review reports glucose (~1 g per chew) – unverified.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$49.99 one-time for 30 servings (150 g) · $1.67 per 5 g
$49.99 one-time for 150 chews (1 g each); 5 chews = 5 g. Subscription $37.49.
Pros
- Pressed tablet rather than a moist gummy (less creatine-degradation risk in principle)
- 1 g per chew makes dosing simple
Cons
- 5 chews per day
- ~3.5x the cost of the brand's powder per 5 g
Certification
- Brand page shows NSF Certified for Sport badge (listing not opened in this research) Unverified
Check before you buy
- NSF Certified for Sport is shown as a badge on the brand page; we did not open the NSF listing.
- A third-party review reports about 1 g glucose per chew; not verified.
Legion Athletics Creatine Gummies (30 servings)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate, 5 g per serving. Naturally flavored/sweetened. Label conflict: iHerb Lemon Drop panel lists 8 g added sugars and 70 kcal per serving, while Legion's comparison table says 'Zero Sugar' – check current label.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$39.99 one-time for 30 servings (150 g) · $1.33 per 5 g
Brand list $39.99 ($1.33/serving); Amazon $34.95. Gummies per serving differ by flavor/label (5 per iHerb Lemon Drop; 4 per a Green Apple listing).
Pros
- Full 5 g dose verified by Labdoor
- Natural sweeteners, no artificial dyes
Cons
- Not NSF/Informed certified (Labdoor is paid by the brand)
- Sugar content unclear across labels
- Expensive vs powder
Certification
- Labdoor certified (brand-paid): 5,920 mg found vs 5,000 mg claimed, heavy metals below USP limits
Check before you buy
- Labels conflict on sugar (one panel lists 8 g added sugars; the brand's comparison table says zero) and on gummies per serving. Check the current label.
Kaged Creatine HCl™ (75 Servings)
What it contains
Creatine hydrochloride (C-HCl™ / CON-CRĒT® creatine HCl per label), 750 mg per scoop. Unflavored: creatine HCl. Fruit Punch / Lemon Lime add natural flavors and sucralose (per Garage Gym Reviews).
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$24.99 one-time for 75 servings (56.2 g) · $2.50 per 5 g monohydrate-equivalent
Regular $24.99; sale $17.49 shown in search snapshot (date of sale not confirmed). Kaged FAQ: 'take four servings daily' (3 g).
Sale price seen: $17.49 (not used in scoring).
Pros
- Informed Sport batch testing
- Small serving volume
Cons
- 750 mg per scoop
- Flavored versions use sucralose
- Expensive per 5 g of creatine
Certification
- Informed Sport (brand: every batch tested) Brand-stated
Check before you buy
- Price comes from a search snapshot of the brand page (the product data could not be loaded directly). The $17.49 sale price was seen but its date is unconfirmed.
Cellucor® Unflavored COR-Performance® Creatine Powder (72 Servings)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (micronized), 5 g per serving. Unflavored: none. Flavored and JOLLY RANCHER versions exist (sweeteners not confirmed).
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$18.99 one-time for 72 servings (360 g) · $0.26 per 5 g
Brand store $18.99 one-time (BOGO 40% promo shown). Flavored 50-serving version $17.99.
Pros
- Cheap per 5 g
- Widely available
Cons
- No verified third-party certification for this creatine
Certification
- No creatine-specific certification confirmed (an Informed Choice list snippet mentions 'Cellucor COR-Performanc…' – unverified) Unverified
Check before you buy
- An Informed Choice list entry mentioning “Cellucor COR-Performanc…” could not be matched to this product. Treat it as uncertified.
Bear Balanced Creatine Gummies (Blueberry; 30 servings / 90 gummies)
What it contains
Creapure® creatine monohydrate, 3.5 g per serving. Creapure® creatine, L-theanine, L-tyrosine, vitamin B12, huperzine A, maltitol, water, xylitol, pectin, citric acid, malic acid, Reb M, natural flavor and color. Sugar-free.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$60.00 one-time for 30 servings (105 g) · $2.86 per 5 g
Brand store: 1 bag (30 servings) $42 (list $60); multi-bag discounts.
Sale price seen: $42.00 (not used in scoring).
Pros
- Passed independent NOW test and publishes lot COAs
- Sugar-free
- Creapure®
Cons
- 3.5 g per 3-gummy serving (below 5 g)
- Adds nootropic ingredients (huperzine A, tyrosine) not needed for creatine
- Sugar alcohols (maltitol/xylitol) may cause GI upset
- Expensive per 5 g
Certification
- Brand-published Eurofins finished-product COAs (4 lots, 111–115% of 3.5 g label)
- Passed NOW Foods 2024 test (116% of claim)
- Brand says tested by NSF lab under Amazon's verification program (not NSF Certified for Sport) Brand-stated
Creatine gummy lab tests, 2024–2026
Looking only for gummies? See our creatine gummies ranking.
Creatine gummies are moist, sweetened products, and creatine can break down into creatinine over time. Independent and semi-independent testing rounds have repeatedly found gummies far below their label claims. Here is every public round we used, with links to the original reports.
-
NOW Foods in-house HPLC testing
6 met label (Bear Balanced, Bod, Effective Nutra, Iron Labs Nutrition, Peach Perfect, Zhou); 6 failed (Astro Labs, Beast Bites, Create, Con-Cret, Greabby, Njord). Con-Cret 28.3 mg vs 250 mg claim; Beast Bites 8.7 mg vs 1,000 mg; Create 1,278 mg vs 1,500 mg. Failing products also contained creatinine.
Caveat: NOW sells creatine and ran the tests itself; single lots.
Sources: wholefoodsmagazine.com · onuroncer.com · supplysidesj.com
-
SuppCo 'Tested' program, ISO 17025 lab
All 5 powders passed (98–101% purity). 4 of 6 gummies failed: Happyummmm 0.005 g vs 5 g per serving (Amazon's Choice best-seller), DivinusLabs 0.025 g vs 5 g, EcoWise and Vidabotan no creatine detected. Create (4.59 g vs 4.5 g) and Force Factor (6.3 g vs 5 g) passed but with notable creatinine.
Sources: supp.co · wired.com · athletechnews.com · isitunderdosed.com
-
Eurofins testing commissioned by UK influencer James Smith
Only Wellboost exceeded claim (5.55 g vs 5 g); three at 95%, 86%, 73%; five had ≤0.11 g per serving (<2% of claim).
Sources: nutraingredients.com
-
Labdoor certificate (brand-paid)
5,920 mg found vs 5,000 mg claimed.
Sources: labdoor.com · getevident.co
What this means if you want a gummy
- Choose a gummy with a current third-party certification or a published independent assay. In our list that means Force Factor (NSF Certified for Sport), Create (NSF Certified for Sport), Legion (Labdoor, brand-paid) or Bear Balanced (published Eurofins COAs).
- Create failed NOW Foods' February 2024 test (about 85% of label) but passed SuppCo's June 2025 test. Results apply to the lots tested.
- Check the serving size: Create gives 4.5 g and Bear Balanced 3.5 g per serving, below 5 g.
Creatine FAQ
What is the best creatine supplement in 2026?
In our ranking, BulkSupplements Creatine Monohydrate scores highest (100/100): it is the cheapest per 5 g we found ($0.15) and holds NSF Certified for Sport listings. If you prefer a widely stocked tub with named NSF Sport listings, Thorne Creatine ($0.47 per 5 g) is our pick for tested athletes. Prices were checked Nov 18, 2026.
Do creatine gummies actually contain creatine?
Not always. In NOW Foods' 2024 testing, 6 of 12 gummy brands failed their label claim. In SuppCo's 2025 test, 4 of 6 gummies failed, including two with no creatine detected. In a 2025 Eurofins round commissioned by James Smith, 5 of 9 brands had 0.11 g or less per serving. Gummies with NSF Certified for Sport (Force Factor, Create) or a Labdoor report (Legion) tested near or above label in the rounds we found.
How much creatine should I take per day?
Creatine monohydrate at 3–5 g per day is the most-studied form and dose. That is why we compare every product on its price per 5 g. Talk to a health professional before starting a supplement, especially if you have a medical condition or take medication.
Is creatine HCl better than creatine monohydrate?
We found no strong head-to-head evidence that it is. Monohydrate is the most-researched form. The two HCl products we ranked (CON-CRĒT and Kaged) provide 750 mg per scoop, well below the 3–5 g/day monohydrate dose used in most research, and they are the most expensive powders per 5 g of creatine in our list.
What is the difference between NSF Certified for Sport, NSF/ANSI 173 and Informed Choice?
NSF Certified for Sport and Informed Sport test lots or batches for banned substances and check the label. NSF/ANSI 173 certification checks contents and contaminants but is not the banned-substance sport program. Informed Choice screens retail lots for banned substances but not label-claim potency. Certification covers the listed lots, flavors and sizes only, so check the registry for your product.
What we couldn't verify
- Prices change often, and Black Friday 2026 promotions were live while we collected them. Check the brand page before you buy.
- Certification is specific to lot, flavor and size, and can lapse. Transparent Labs' and Momentous Chews' NSF Certified for Sport status came from secondary reports or the brand page; we didn't open those NSF listings.
- Cellucor's Informed Choice status is unverified, so we scored it as uncertified.
- ConsumerLab's June 2026 creatine review is paywalled; its results were not used.